The voluntary carbon market made measurable progress in pricing transparency in 2025, but persistent weaknesses in credit quality continue to weigh on confidence, according to a new joint report from Calyx Global and ClearBlue Markets.
The study, titled “The State of Quality and Pricing in the VCM: 2026,” finds that price differentiation between high- and low-quality carbon credits widened sharply over the year, suggesting that buyers are becoming more selective after years of criticism over inflated and unreliable offsets.
Credits rated in the highest integrity tiers traded at prices nearly 50% higher than those at the lowest end, a marked shift from earlier periods when weaker credits often fetched comparable—or even higher—prices.

Despite this advance in price discovery, the overall integrity of credits issued and retired remains modest.
Average quality scores for issuances improved only slightly, while retirements showed clearer gains, indicating that companies are increasingly choosing better credits even as new supply struggles to keep pace.
Large volumes of low-rated credits—particularly from legacy REDD and hydropower projects—continued to drag down market-wide averages.
Relevant: Calyx Global Opens Carbon Credit Ratings Platform To the Public
Pricing patterns varied widely by project type. Nature-based credits showed the strongest alignment between integrity and price, reflecting years of scrutiny and growing buyer familiarity.
Household and community projects, such as cookstoves, also exhibited widening price spreads, with higher-quality projects commanding significantly higher values.
By contrast, so-called super pollutant credits, including methane and industrial gas mitigation, displayed weak price differentiation, underscoring limited market understanding of these project types.
The report challenges the common assumption that carbon removal projects are inherently higher quality than avoidance projects.
Data reviewed across more than 1,000 rated projects shows similar integrity distributions between the two categories, even as removal credits continue to trade at higher prices.
This disconnect suggests buyers are often rewarding project labels rather than underlying climate performance.

Credits certified under the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market’s Core Carbon Principles performed better on average than the broader market and are beginning to attract modest price premiums, although the report cautions that the label alone does not guarantee high integrity.
Looking ahead, the authors argue that targeted reforms—such as accelerating improved REDD methodologies, avoiding non-additional renewable energy credits, and tightening baselines for forest management projects—could dramatically raise overall market quality.
Without a decisive move away from low-integrity supply, however, confidence in the voluntary carbon market is likely to recover only slowly.
Read more: ClearBlue Markets Launches The Sustainability Leader’s Guide To The Voluntary Carbon Market








