Quality Carbon Removal Commands A Premium, But It Must Be Delivered

Quality Carbon Removal Commands A Premium, But It Must Be Delivered - Carbon Herald
Alex Clayton is chief carbon officer at Gevo, Inc.. Photo: Gevo Inc.

Buyers Willing to Pay Triple, as BCG Finds, Should Check the Retirement Date as Closely as the Rating

Carbon credit buyers have made it clear they will pay for quality. Boston Consulting Group’s (BCG) latest survey of about 300 buyers found target portfolio prices have roughly tripled since 2022. BCG also found buyers can’t get enough of what they want, estimating they would spend about $800 million more a year if enough credits met their quality requirements.

For carbon removal, I’d argue another often-overlooked requirement is whether the tonnes will be available when buyers need them.

Quality and timing

BCG defines carbon integrity as “whether a credit’s climate impact is reliably measurable and verifiable,” and the survey found buyers weigh trusted registries and rigorous measurement above everything else. A forward contract requiring ex post credits can be well designed and the project behind it well rated, but credits can’t be issued until the removals have occurred and have been verified. CO2 also keeps trapping heat every day it stays in the atmosphere, so a tonne removed in 2026 starts working right away, while a tonne promised for the 2030s does nothing until it arrives. The market has so far left that difference largely unpriced.

Timing also matters for a practical reason. That signed contract gives a buyer the right to a tonne, but the buyer can’t unequivocally claim the impact until the CO2 has been captured and stored, the data packaged, a third party has audited it, the registry has issued the credit, and the credit has been transferred. These steps take time. Many portfolios are modeled on the delivery date specified when the contract was signed, but the date that matters is when the tonnes can be retired, and the two often drift meaningfully apart.

Budgets point the same way

BCG also found that buyers’ budgets are being fully utilized. The average target budget is $58 a tonne, just $3 above what their portfolios cost today but well below the $79 a tonne needed to match quality preferences. So how does additional impact find its way in? Direct air capture suppliers’ median ask is about $900 a tonne and fewer than one in 10 buyers would consider it at that price. Bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) and biochar rank among the credit types buyers find most credible and BCG places them in a “workable middle ground,” where roughly three-quarters of buyers would consider them at prices suppliers are asking. That middle ground is expanding and it is also where verified tonnes are available today, including from BECCS projects like ours in North Dakota.

Three things you can do this quarter

For buyers who want more control of their impact and the tonnes they can retire when they need them, I recommend starting with these three steps:

1. Re-cut the portfolio by delivery year.

Most reviews sort by volume and technology mix. Add delivery year as a third axis, adjust tonnes for delivery risk and run it again. A portfolio that looks balanced by credit type or geographic exposure can be badly lopsided by delivery certainty, with the bulk of its committed impact landing after the year it was bought to serve. This takes an afternoon and a spreadsheet. I’d do it before signing anything else.

2. Set a floor on already-delivering supply.

Decide what share of the portfolio must come from projects that have already issued credits on a public registry, then hold that line. This may not have ever been a considered criterion for the portfolio today. Everything above the floor is where earlier-stage technology belongs. And please, go get it because we need it all to come to market.

3. Re-underwrite delivery every year.

It’s possible for a project that looked solid at signing to slip. Once a year, ask for the items you can check with and without the supplier’s help: issuance history against prior vintages, the most recent third-party audit, and whether the contracted delivery schedule still lines up with the project’s own regulatory filings. Projects with a permitting footprint usually publish monitoring data independently of the developer, so you don’t have to take anyone’s word for it. Intermediaries have tools that can help here too. If a supplier can’t show issuance against a previous vintage, what you’re holding is a forecast, and you should treat it like one.

Building on proven removal

BCG found that buyers prefer diversified portfolios with durable engineered removals making up roughly a fifth to a quarter of them. An anchor of removal that’s already running and independently verified is what makes that diversification work. With it in place, a corporate buyer can take on more risk elsewhere in the portfolio, knowing a core of its tonnes will be ready to retire when needed.

Our Richardton, North Dakota, project is one example. Since 2022, it has captured biogenic CO2 from ethanol fermentation and injected it into a Class VI well on the same site. It holds an A rating from BeZero Carbon, and more than 620,000 of its credits have been issued as CO2 Removal Certificates (CORCs) on Puro.earth.

In September, Whirlpool added durable removal from the project to a carbon removal portfolio managed by ClimeFi, alongside three other pathways. Whirlpool’s mix of pathways matches the approach I’ve laid out here. Both companies also highlighted benefits for rural and farming communities. A cooperative of more than 300 area farmers built the plant, creating a local market for their corn and creating community infrastructure.

Looking Ahead

This next cycle is going to be important. A spot plus three-year forward contract could cover deliveries from 2027 through 2030. This is not a contract you want to fully replace. The spot, in-year delivery shows it can be done and, ultimately, the forward three-year offtake secures you for when it matters.

Alex Clayton is chief carbon officer at Gevo, Inc., where he leads the company’s carbon removal business and its work in the voluntary carbon market. Gevo produces low-carbon fuels and owns and operates a BECCS carbon removal project in Richardton, North Dakota, that has permanently stored biogenic CO2 since 2022.

Related Posts
Translate »
Total
0
Share