Opinion: Europe’s CCS Market Is Maturing – What’s Working?

Opinion: Europe’s CCS Market Is Maturing – What’s Working? - Carbon Herald
Image courtesy of the Global CCS Institute

Europe is showing how regionally appropriate policy and funding frameworks can take CCS from individual projects to connected industrial markets, says Dr Richard Leese, Head of Europe at the Global CCS Institute. 

It’s too early to call Europe a carbon capture and storage (CCS) success story, but the foundations   of a functioning market are taking shape. Our Global Status of CCS report shows that the region is now home to 13 per cent of the world’s operational projects and accounts for more than one third of the global pipeline under construction. An acceleration in deployment will be needed to meet the Net-Zero Industry Act target to achieve at least 50 million tonnes of annual CO₂ injection capacity by 2030, but for now at least it remains an achievable goal. 

More than the project count, Europe is beginning to demonstrate how a connected market could operate in practice – from Yara shipping CO2 from the Netherlands and storing it off the coast of Norway via Northern Lights, to Greensand entering into commercial operation and taking steps to offer storage as an industrial service. 

So what’s working, and what can other parts of the world learn from Europe’s experience?

The fundamentals enabling growth

To some extent the key ingredients are the same as they ever were: state support, including funding, and a strong legislative framework that financial decisions can be made against. Northern Lights has shown the power of the public purse as a first mover to get projects off the ground and sustain them while private investment crowds in.

The Norwegian government’s backing of the scheme has allowed other companies to tap into the storage asset and tackled the ‘what comes first’ conundrum for emitters looking to capture carbon dioxide. This success could expand southward, with the European Commission selecting Eni and Snam’s Ravenna CCS Phase 2 project for support through the 2025 Innovation Fund.

Consistency has also played a significant part. There is a strong policy, legal and regulatory framework for CCS, with the EU setting the CO2 injection capacity mandate on oil and gas companies through the Net Zero Industry Act. There are challenges too, of course, given the political focus on energy security, industrial competitiveness and affordability considerations, but the direction of travel is largely unchanged. If private investment is to come forward, then that certainty in the future policy environment is absolutely essential. 

What the future looks like

Forthcoming enabling activity could help to tackle remaining gaps in the legislative framework. The Commission’s CO2 transport and infrastructure package will hopefully address some of the cross-border technicalities of moving CO2, including the potential for harmonised specifications and third-party access which will help determine responsibility boundaries between operators.

This would pave the way for businesses to mitigate against potential losses and open up the potential for insurers to create new products. The EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) review could also solve some of the cross-border accounting questions through surrender exemptions for qualifying permanent storage in third countries with linked ETS systems.

Relevant: Global CCS Institute Maps Latest Carbon Capture Technologies As CCS Sector Expands

The EU ETS review also proposes integration of domestic permanent BioCCS and DACCS removals via a centralised Commission purchasing mechanism, funded by the sale of 250 million allowances (2031 to 2040), plus another 10 million if needed, therefore signalling the potential for carbon management project pipeline expansion.   

The drivers of CCS to date have largely been ones of push factors, with industries working to meet their decarbonisation requirements and avoid emissions costs. In time, the ‘pull’ of the demand for low-carbon products could help to build the business case for deployment, kickstarted by the Industrial Accelerator Act’s proposals to back lower emissions goods in public procurement and public support schemes.

Lessons to take to COP31

As the world prepares for COP31 in Antalya, the focus should increasingly be on implementation: turning climate commitments into investable projects and operating infrastructure. Carbon management has a role alongside electrification, renewable energy, energy efficiency and other mitigation measures, particularly in hard-to-abate sectors. The next step is to translate recognition of the importance of carbon management in national climate plans into action.

The political, financial, geological, industrial and legislative realities of different regions will shape different pathways to CCS deployment, but Europe demonstrates what is possible when governments create the conditions for projects to move. The lesson is not that every market needs an identical strategy. It is that sustained political commitment, targeted public investment and practical delivery can allow a market to emerge even before every element of policy architecture is complete. Norway, after all, has advanced carbon management without a dedicated CCS strategy. 

Read more: GCCA And Global CCS Institute To Accelerate Carbon Capture Adoption In Cement Industry

Related Posts
Translate »
Total
0
Share